Here are the beer cellar reviews, listed according to their scores. Those graded with identical scores are listed together, without any significance to their internal order.
| Top Scoring | Alphabetical (by beer) | Alphabetical (by brewery) |
| Beer | Brewery | ABV (%) | Comments | Score:/10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I Beer | Art Brew | 4.00 | Light golden, with soft honey and vanilla aroma and taste. Bitter aftertaste. Vanilla follow through dominates, possibly to excess. | 6.0 |
| Imperial Stout | Youngs | 10.00 | Smooth, rice, with everything that an imperial stout should be. Maybe not different enough to chocolate stout in quality to warrant the price difference. (Rem: it's in smaller bottles, too!) | 8.0 |
| Indian Pale Ale | Rise Bryggeri | 5.50 | Pleasant golden colour but undiscernable aroma. On a par with most other UK IPA's however a little less bitter. Slight caramel after taste. Organic version is more sour, this is sweeter. | 7.3 |
| Ingwer | C K Brower | 0.00 | Smooth, light fizz. Touch of giners | 8.0 |
| IPA | Meantime | 7.50 | Masculine beer, with aromatic nose. Light but full bitterness, with slight rough after-taste. | 8.0 |
| IPA | Meantime | 7.50 | Caramel fused with Belgium-based blonde. Full, bouncy, with sparkling bitter on tongue in a/t. | 8.0 |
| IPA is Dead - Challenger | Brewdog | 6.70 | Hop-based, light ale, following with a light cream. A real contrast to the other two. I think I was offered this to offset the cost of the others, actually! It is too hoppy for me to session this, but a good, but not remarkable beer. | 7.5 |
| iron Brew | Freeminer | 4.20 | A red ale, but without anything much to say. Nothing bad. Nothing great. | 7.0 |