Here are the beer cellar reviews, listed according to their scores. Those graded with identical scores are listed together, without any significance to their internal order.
| Top Scoring | Alphabetical (by beer) | Alphabetical (by brewery) |
| Beer | Brewery | ABV (%) | Comments | Score:/10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yakima Gold | Crouch Vale | 4.20 | Very pale with earthy aroma. Amarillo hops. Passable, if unadventurous. | 7.0 |
| Yarlington Mill | Gwatkins | 8.00 | Fizzy golden yellow cider. Full-on apple aroma. Slightly too much syrup. Clean. No sediment. | 8.5 |
| Yellow Cab Lager | Evil Twin Brewing | 4.80 | Pale and clear lager, lacking depth of interest | 6.0 |
| Yo-ho Tokyo Black | Yo-Ho Brewery | 5.00 | Festival special. Robust porter, good bitterness. Chocolate and black malts. | 7.0 |
| Yore | Lyme Bay Winery | 4.00 | Like a popularist cider: bright, sparkling, fun, but with honey through line | 7.5 |
| Yule Ale | Rise Bryggeri | 7.00 | Reddish ale with sweet and slightly spicy tang and gentle fizz. Has notes of a less rich ESB. Touch of banana. | 9.0 |